Q. What are the special points to which an auditor must pay special attention in vouching receipts (debit side of cash book) ?
Ans. Vouching of the Receipts side of a cashbook is more complicated as compared to the vouching of the payment side because the evidence of receipts is not direct since the payment of such receipts is made to other parties and the entries in the cash book is made internally.
The auditor therefore, needs to be extra careful in checking the receipts side in a cash book. He must keep in mind the following:
1. Internal Checking: The auditor needs to satisfy himself that the internal check system in operation is good and reasonably reliable. He needs to understand the rules and regulations for issuing receipts, making records thereof and dealing with banks, etc. This becomes necessary to ensure that there is no misappropriation of funds, which can only be done by a thorough examination. For example, check a few items at random and if he finds them to be in order and free from irregularities, he has the reason to assume the remaining ones will be correct.
2. List of Receipts: The auditor needs to examine that all receipts received in a day and the amount of cash thererof s recording in a list of receipts, and that the same are recorded in the diary or the rough cash book and later in the cash book. He must check the two from time to time.
3. Reconciliation of Cash Books: At the start of the audit, the auditor should examine the rough cash book or the diary and compare it with the cashbook, because there is always the possibility that some items recorded in the rough cash book might not have been recorded in the cash book.
4. Receipt Issue System: Another point to be noted by the auditor is that there is Receipt Issue System, and a proper control over the use of Receipt Book. He should keep in mind the following points:
(i) That all receipts are on printed forms.
(ii) That there is a counterfoil or carbon copy of each receipt.
(iii) That all receipts and receipt books are separately and consecutively numbered.
(iv) That the particulars in the receipts, i.e. the date, amount, name, etc. are the same as recorded in the cashbook.
(v) Blank Receipt Books must be in the custody of an authorised and responsible member of the staff.
(vi) The receipt must be signed by the authorized member(s) of the staff.
(vii) There should be no other signature on the receipt except that of the authorised signatory.
(viii) If there is a system under which a receipt accompanies the receipt of cash, search your receipt (usually known as delivery note) should be properly signed before its return to the customer.
(ix) There should be a strict observance of the system of keeping the counterfoil or carbon copy of each receipt.
(x) In case a receipt of the written wrongly or has to be cancelled for any reason, it should not be taken out of the Receipt Book, and the word ‘Cancelled’ should be written on the receipt.
5. Bank Deposit System: In case the recepts are deposited in the bank, then the total of the receipts deposited should be reconciled with the bank’s pay-in-slips. It also needs to be checked that the counterfoils of the bank’s pay-in-slips are duly signed and stamped by the bank’s officer.
6. Abiding by the Rules: In case there are any other rules in vogue for granting receipts, making records thereof or dealing with the bank, these should be strictly be adhered to.
Important Items of Receipts Side (Debit Side)
1. Cash Sales: The system of internal check of cash sales is of utmost importance in a business. The auditor should check the carbon duplicates of the cash memos with the summaries of cash sales. He should compare the sales abstract with the cash analysis and then check up the cash book. In case the auditor detects any discrepancy, he should immediately inform the client.
The possibilities of fraud or misappropriation are more in cash sales. The auditor, therefore, must be extra careful in vouching cash sales. As Lancaster has very aptly put it, “Vouching of sales is more difficult than that of purchases.”
Vouchers: Carbon duplicates of cash memos, salesman’s abstracts, cashier’s summaries.
2. Cash Received from Debtors: Firstly, it is necessary to ensure that the staff who receives cash from the debtors is not involved in making the statement of such receipts. Whatever the amount received from the debtors is acknowledged by a receipt which is issued. The cash received from debtors can be vouched by referring to the counterfoils of the receipts issued to them.
The auditor should pay special attention to the discount allowed to customers and the bad debts that are written off. He should acquaint himself with the method and rate of granting discount. The discount rates should not exceed the percentage that has been predefined. The auditor should enquire who has the authority to write off bad debts and if these are written off by thè authorised person.
Vouchers: Receipt counterfoils, details of the account, correspondence and authorisation certificates of concerned officials.
3. Amount Received from Bills Receivable: The auditor needs to check the cash receipts of the bills receivable for which the relevant amounts have been received and Bills Receivable Book with the Cash Book and the Pass Book. He should also scrutinise the rebate that has given on bill received prior to the due date, and make sure that rebate given on such bill conforms to the accepted norms of the business. The amount deducted at discount or rebate on these bills should be debited in the discount account.
The auditor needs to pay special attention to the bills that have matured, but the amount of the bills has not been received, and should get a certificate from the authorised person that the payment has not been received. He should investigate further to make sure that the dishonoured or retired bills have not been paid and that there is no discrepancy or misappropriation.
Vouchers: Bill Receivable Book, Cash Book, Pass Book.
4. Income from Interest and Dividend: Interest and dividend are receivable from different sources and, as such, their vouchers are also different. Interest is normally received from: (i) Investments, (ii) Loans and (iii) Deposits in Banks. The rate of interest on investments and security is the fixed rate and should be checked with the help of the counterfoils of interest coupons. In the case of interest received on a loan given to borrower, the relevant agreement between the borrower and the business should be checked to determine the rate of interest. At the same time, it should be checked whether or not the interest received has been recorded in the account books on the relevant dates. If the interest is received on fixed deposit in the bank, such income should be vouched with the Bank Pass Book or the Interest Statement that can be obtained from the bank.
In case of receipt of dividends, three vounchers, namely: counterfoils, share certificates, dividend warrants and letters received along with the cheques need to be examined. If such income is collected through the bank, the passbook needs to be referred to. The auditor should make sure that the income so received or accrued has been accounted for in the books of accounts and the balance sheet.
Vouchers: Pass Book, agreements, schedule, counterfoils, dividend warrants.
5. Rent Received: To vouch the rent received, it is necessary to examine the relevant lease deeds or rent agreements and assertain the amount of rent payable and the provisions regarding repairs. The auditor should check the counterfoils of the rent receipts issued to the tenants. If any agents are appointed to collect rent, the accounts or statements submitted by them should be checked. The auditor needs to be particularly careful to check the outstanding rent because the rent might have been received but shown as outstanding and the rent amount may have been misappropriated.
Vouchers: Lease deeds and agreements, rent rolls, accounts received from agents, counterfoils, correspondence.
6. Commission Received: As a general rule, there is an agreement between the business and the parties from whom the commission is receivable. The rate of the commission payable can be found from such agreement, and the amount of commission paid can be ascertained from the statement of commission. The entries made in the cashbook can be vouched from the counterfoils of receipts. If the commission has been received in respect of goods received on consignment, the amount of commission should be vouched by comparing it with the copy of account sale sent to the consignor. In case it is necessary, the auditor can make the required calculations himself.
Vouchers: Commission agreement, statement of commission, receipt counterfoils, correspondence.
7. Subscription Received: The receipt that is given when a subscription is received should be confirmed by checking the relevant counterfoil. The amounts of subscriptions received can be vouched with the help of the subscriptions register and receipt counterfoils. The auditor should also check the subscriptions received in advance end the outstanding subscriptions at the end of the accounting year.
Vouchers: Register of subscriptions, counterfoils, correspondence.
8. Proceeds of Hire Purchase: The auditor needs to examine the Hire Purchase Agreement to assertain the duration of the agreement, the amount of installments payable by the close of the accounting period. It should be kept in mind that the installment is not credited in sales account — it has to be properly apportioned between sales and interest.
Vouchers: Hire purchase agreement, receipt counterfoils, correspondence.
9. Proceeds from Sale of Investments: Investments are normally sold through brokers. The brokers send a sold note that contains the details of the amounts received from the sale and the commission chargable by the broker. Vouching the sale proceeds of investments is done by the sold note of the brokers. It is therefore important to check the broker's sold note. In case there is any agreement or correspondence related to the sale of investments, it should also be examined.
If the investments have been sold cum-dividend, it should be assertain that the dividend has been received and apportioned between capital and revenue. In case the sale of investment is ex-dividend, the relevant entry must be checked by the auditor.
Vouchers: Broker’s sold note, receipt counterfoils, correspondence.
10. Receipts from the Sale of Other Assets: When whenever the fixed assets of a business are sold, they are sold through: (i) or sales representative or a broker and (ii) an auction of the assets. In case the sale is through the medium of a sales representative or a broker, it can be vouched by examining the note of the broker or the sales representative. If the sale of assests is by auction, the auctioneer’s note needs to be examined to vouch the transaction. Besides this, if a sale deed or a contact of sale is the medium, such deed or contract should be examined by the auditor. Thus the auditor can scrutinise the sale proceeds of assets by the broker’s or auctioneer’s note, or the sale deed or sale contract.
Vouchers: Broker’s or auctioneer’s note, sale deed or contract, correspondence.
11. Claims Received Under Insurance Policy: In case of any claims received under an insurance policy, the vouching is done by examining the insurance policy, the claim letter, they accounts surddeed by the valuer and insurer, and the correspondence between the client and the insurer.
Vouchers: Report of the valuer and insurer, correspondence, Bank Pass Book.
12. Refund of Income Tax: While vouching the refund of income tax, the auditor should ensure that the amount so received is duly entered in the account books of the business. Besides this, the claim for such refund, related correspondence and the statement of the tax authority should also be examined.
Vouchers: Claim for tax refund, related correspondence, etc.
13. Bad debts Recovered: Under the provisions of the Insolvency Act, when a person or a business is declared to be insolvent, the court appoints a liquidator who takes over the assets of the insolvent, and pays the creditors of the insolvent, and pays the creditors of insolvent proportionately to their credit from the money realised from the sale of the assets taken over. The amount so received by the creditors is called bad debts dividend. Vouching for the recovery of bad debts is done by examining the dividend letters, receipts and related correspondence.
Vouchers: Dividend letters, receipts, correspondence.
14. Receipts from Sale of Shares: In order to vouch such receipts, the auditor should use the register of members, or the allotment register and the share register. In this context, he should also refer to the ‘Minutes Books’ of the meetings of Board of Directors.
15. Remittance from agents: Every agent makes out a detail of his account and sends it to the organization. Normally, the detail is forwarded to an employee, in every organization, who examines these details minutely and thereafter, makes enries in the cashbook based on these details.
While examining amounts received from agents, the auditor should consider the detail received from the agent as the voucher, and tally it with the entries in the cashbook.
Vouchers: Correspondence with agents, details received from agents.
16. Other Receipts: The documents related to such receipts should be examined. In case such documents are not available, the auditor should correspond with the concerned parties to vouch such receipts.
voching receipts debit side cash book auditor special points
